There’s been an astonishing amount of commentary surrounding the recent releases of the Microsoft Seinfeld ads and the new “I’m a PC” campaign. I’ve read hundreds of comments in blogs and forums lately and I’m staggered at how pathetic most of them are. As a Mac user ( I have 5, plus a bunch of iPods and other Apple bits) I subscribe to most of the well known Apple sites for news. As a marketer, I also look at the marketing from both Apple and Microsoft and see who is taking what position. Hmmm….
What is really pissing me off is the level of idiocy in Mac Fanboy culture. While, I love my Macs, I fucking hate fanboys even if I might have tended toward that slippery slope once or twice myself. Mac Fanboys are bullshit artists and sycophantic historical revisionists who take a self-important stance because they chose to plant their flag in one technological corner. Now your Mac zealot is a fucking marketing expert as well!! I’ve got news for you pack of losers…you know nothing!
Let’s go back to basics and relook at the two platforms.
1. They are the same animal hardware-wise. Sure the iMac is an elegant machine. It’s beautiful and it just gets better. But there are PC manufacturers making machines just as nice. Some of the new HPs are very interesting and are quite beautiful as well. Sony Vaios are also quite attractive although Sony are pretty loose canons most of the time and are capable of making beautiful junk. So let’s eliminate the hardware from the equation because I just can’t see a single area that Apple hardware is superior to PC and you could equally argue that much PC gear is in fact, better than Apple.
2. Mac don’t do games. I know they CAN do games but that’s pretty recent and you have a choice of about 4 to pick from. I also know that consoles own the gaming market now but I can still buy or download eleventy billion games for the PC. If half of them are shit and full of bugs THAT’S NOT MICROSOFT’S FAULT. The fact that you can eventually get them going on a PC is itself a friggin’ technological miracle. You can’t get close on a Mac.
3. If we eliminate hardware and games that leaves productivity and internet. Let’s look at productivity first and the best place to start is Microsoft Office. In it’s current incarnation for Windows, Office is awesome. It is totally bullet-proof and it does pretty much everything you need for a business. I have used it since it was invented and I use it for real in large companies doing real business-type work and I love it. If you don’t then go and use Lotus and see how fucking good Office is. I’ve used Wordperfect as well and yes, it was good. In fact, it did things that Word still doesn’t do as well. However, the marginal utility that afforded me was nothing compared to the benefits of Office. Word, Excel and Outlook work together quite well and the Wordperfect suite was shit. Lotus was OK but only OK. Office rules and is used by everyone so you don’t have to train a new recruit because people just know how to use it now. That’s the benefit from being a near monopoly. I’m sure there are geeks who will wee their pants because they’ve found the odd thing Office doesn’t do and they got some freeware that does it but only four people in the world use. Good on ‘em. Just stay the fuck away from any business I work in.
Apart from Office, PC own enterprise. For years I’ve used workstations on Dell, HP or IBM networks without too much failure and since Windows XP rarely a crash.The Dell network we use now is pretty robust and sure there are incidents but no more than you’d get on XServe networks or Unix. Outlook and Exchange server are great. Not perfect but go and use Lotus Domino and you’ll beg for Microsoft. I don’t want to get into open source vs proprietary platforms; this is about Mac vs PC and I am very pro PHP and MySQL against ASP and MS-SQL but only for cost.
Outside the enterprise environment, lets look at creative arts. Brands like Adobe, Corel etc. They all work on both platforms and just as well. There is a large enough benefit in the way Macs deploy these apps to give them a clear market share and a higher than PC take up. But if the Large Hadron Collider created a black hole that only sucked in Apple gear, graphics and music studios would still get their work done on PCs. The reality is that Mac offer no universal advantage over PC at all despite areas of specific advantage.
Mac do come with the iLife suite, which is good but not great. In fact, it gets progressively worse. iPhoto is so restrictive I just hate it. I can’t get to anything easily and now the database folder is packaged up. The problem is, I’m so locked into iPhoto and iTunes, the pain-in-the arse factor is too high to change. I do like iMovie but iChat is shit and so is iWeb. Dot Mac was lame and from all accounts Mobile Me is lamer and busted.
4. Internet. OK. At the moment a clear advantage to Mac. Not because of any usability gain but simply because of security. When I sold Apple gear this was the clincher. You sold Apple on coolness and security and hid the fact they do very little that’s significantly better than PC. However, a large part of Mac’s advantage over PC is the small market share it occupies making it a lower risk. That will change. It will change because Macs will become exposed and Windows will get more secure until they are the same. Enjoy it while it lasts. Oh, and browsers…don’t go there. Safari is now on Windows and Firefox 3 has pwned Safari.
So there you go. Platforms compared there’s little to separate them. That’s today. The fanboys are also historical revisionists so let’s take a look at the relative strengths of the platforms in the next post.
Filed under: Diatribe | Tagged: Apple, computers, fanboy, I'm a Mac, iLife, iPhoto, Mac, Microsoft, Microsoft Office, PC, productivity, Seinfeld, Windows | Leave a Comment »